How to Order Like a Regular at a Speakeasy

Skip the menu question

A lot of the best rooms on this trail run little to no printed menu — Attaboy famously has none at all. The worst way to open that conversation is 'what do you recommend,' which forces the bartender to guess at your taste from nothing. Give them three real pieces of information instead: a base spirit, a flavor direction (bright and citrus-forward, dark and boozy, bitter), and how strong you want it. 'Something with rye, not too sweet, stirred' will get you a far better drink than 'surprise me.'

If a room does run a menu, read it before you order rather than at the bar rail while people wait behind you. Most menus on speakeasy-style lists are organized by era or spirit for a reason — Prohibition-original programs often group drinks the way Harry Craddock did in the Savoy Cocktail Book, by base spirit, which tells you something about the room's priorities before you've had a sip.

The order that signals you know what you're doing

Naming the drink correctly matters more than people think. A Sazerac is rye or cognac, absinthe-rinsed, no ice in the glass. An Old Fashioned ordered 'with soda' is technically a Presbyterian, and a good bartender will make either one but will clock which one you actually meant. If you don't know a drink's construction, it is entirely acceptable — and preferred — to ask 'what's in it' rather than order blind and complain later.

Asking for a drink 'dirty,' 'up,' 'neat,' or 'on the rocks' correctly is a small thing that changes how a bartender treats the rest of your order. Up means stirred or shaken and served without ice in a stemmed glass. Neat means poured with nothing added, no ice, in a rocks glass. Confusing the two is the single most common ordering mistake at a serious bar.

Tipping and tabs

Tip per round, not just at the end of the night, especially at a bar with no table service where you're ordering directly at the rail. A dollar or two per drink on a cash tab, or 20 percent on a card tab closed at the end, is the going rate at almost every room on this trail. Bartenders remember who tipped on the first round when it comes to the fourth.

If a room has a house tab system — common at speakeasies that don't want guests flashing cards at a hidden bar — open it early and settle it without being asked when your night is winding down. Making a bartender chase you for a tab at 1am is the fastest way to be remembered for the wrong reason.

Small talk that works, and small talk that doesn't

Bartenders in these rooms are usually happy to talk about a drink's history or ingredients if you ask a specific question — 'is this a pre-Prohibition recipe' or 'what's the bitters in this' will almost always get a genuine, interested answer. Vague chat ('you must see everything in here, huh') gets a polite, short one, because it's not actually a question.

Don't ask a bartender to make you something 'stronger' after they've already built the drink to spec. If you want more spirit, say so up front — 'can you build that a little more spirit-forward' — before the shake or stir, not as a complaint afterward.

The regulars' unwritten rules

Regulars rarely order off-menu novelties designed to test the bartender ('surprise me with something weird'); they order things that are hard to make well, which is a better compliment. They also don't linger at the service end of the bar where drinks are actually being built and handed to servers — that's a work zone, not a good seat.

Above all, patience reads as competence. A drink built with care takes longer than a well drink at a sports bar. Standing at the rail visibly impatient after ninety seconds tells the room you don't belong in it; most good bartenders will simply slow down further in response.

Questions

What's the right way to ask for a strong drink without sounding rude?

Ask for it 'built spirit-forward' before the drink is made, rather than asking for it to be remade stronger afterward.

Is it okay to ask a bartender to make something not on the menu?

Yes, at most speakeasy-style bars — that's often the entire point of a no-menu program. Give them a spirit, a flavor direction, and a strength, and let them build it.

Styles in this guide

Links go to Amazon. We may earn a commission on purchases at no extra cost to you.

Keep reading